When Rest Feels Unsafe: Why Slowing Down Can Make Anxiety Worse

A quiet road, a long night, and nowhere to rush to. Winter invites rest.

One of the most confusing things I hear from people is this:

“I finally have a break… and I feel worse.”

They slow down.
They rest.
They cancel plans.
They stop pushing.

And instead of relief, they feel more anxious, more restless, or more emotionally overwhelmed.

If that sounds familiar, nothing is wrong with you.

When rest doesn’t automatically feel safe

For people who’ve spent a long time in survival mode, rest doesn’t automatically feel safe.

When your nervous system has learned that staying alert, productive, or emotionally guarded is what keeps things together, slowing down can feel like letting go of control. And your system responds accordingly — with anxiety, agitation, racing thoughts, or a sudden urge to do something.

This is often when people start judging themselves:

• “Why can’t I relax?”

• “Why am I still on edge?”

• “I should feel better by now.”

But those reactions aren’t failures.
They’re protective responses.

Why slowing down can make things feel worse

Rest removes distractions.

And when distractions fade, whatever your nervous system has been holding finally has space to surface. That can include old fears, unresolved stress, grief, or emotions that never had time to land.

So instead of calm, your system sounds the alarm.

This is why advice like “just rest more” can feel frustrating or even invalidating. Rest isn’t neutral when your body has learned to stay braced to survive.

A trauma-informed way of understanding rest

In trauma-informed therapy, we don’t assume that slowing down is always the goal.

Instead, we ask:

• What does your nervous system associate with rest?

• When did slowing down stop feeling safe?

• What parts of you learned they had to stay alert to protect you?

Sometimes the work isn’t about resting more — it’s about helping your system learn that it doesn’t have to stay on guard all the time.

That learning happens slowly, through safety, choice, and regulation — not force.

What helps when rest feels unsafe

If rest tends to increase anxiety or overwhelm, these approaches can help gently build safety over time:

• Start with micro-rest, not full stopping (short pauses, quiet moments with structure)

• Add predictability to rest (same chair, same time of day, same routine)

• Orient to your environment (notice where you are, what feels solid or neutral)

• Pair rest with something regulating, like warmth, music, or gentle movement

• Allow co-regulation, such as resting near someone safe rather than alone

• Work with the nervous system, not against it — forcing calm often backfires

There is no “right” way to rest. Safety comes before stillness.

If this resonates

If you find yourself feeling stuck, anxious, or emotionally reactive during periods when you “should” feel better, it doesn’t mean you’re broken or doing healing wrong.

It means your nervous system learned what it needed to in order to survive.

And with the right kind of support, it can also learn that rest doesn’t have to be dangerous anymore.

If slowing down feels overwhelming rather than restorative, you don’t have to navigate that alone. Trauma-informed therapy can help your nervous system find steadier ground — without pushing, fixing, or rushing.

📞 Call or text: 343-587-2021
📅 Book here: https://aws-portal.owlpractice.ca/wanderingwillow/booking